Adult Day Care vs Home Care: Which Is Right for Your Family?
2 weeksFamilies exploring care options for an aging or disabled loved one often frame the decision as
adult day care OR home care. In reality, many families use both — and the combination is often
stronger than either one alone. Here’s how the two compare and when each makes sense.
What Each Provides
Adult day care takes place at a center — like SarahCare — during daytime hours. Your loved
one attends a structured program with activities, meals, health monitoring, and socialization,
then comes home in the evening. The care is group-based but individualized.
Home care takes place in the home, with an aide providing one-on-one personal care,
homemaker services, and daily living support. The care is entirely individualized and happens
on the family’s schedule.
When Adult Day Is the Better Fit
Adult day care is stronger when your loved one benefits from social engagement and peer
interaction (isolation is a risk at home), they have dementia and respond well to structured
routines, the family caregiver works during the day and needs reliable daytime coverage, and
your loved one is mobile enough to attend a center and participate in group activities.
When Home Care Is the Better Fit
Home care is stronger when your loved one has mobility limitations that make traveling to a
center difficult, their care needs are primarily physical (bathing, dressing, toileting) rather
than social, they’re resistant to group settings or uncomfortable around unfamiliar people, and
the family prefers one-on-one care in a familiar environment.
When Both Work Together
The most comprehensive care arrangements we see combine both. The family caregiver (often
a paid CareChoice caregiver) provides personal care at home during mornings, evenings, and
weekends. SarahCare provides structured daytime programming Monday through Friday. The
result: near-complete coverage with social engagement, personal care, health monitoring, and
caregiver respite all built in.
This isn’t theoretical — it’s how many of our families in the Philadelphia area actually structure
their care. Both services can be Medicaid-funded through Community HealthChoices, and the
MCO’s service coordinator can build both into a single care plan.
Cost Comparison
Service Medicaid-Funded Private Pay
Adult day (5 days/week) $0 to family Varies by center
Home care (30 hrs/week) $0 to family $25–$35/hour
Both combined $0 to family Higher but comprehensive
For Medicaid-eligible families, the answer is clear: both services can be covered at no out-of-pocket cost. There’s no financial reason to choose one over the other when the care plan
supports both.
Contact SarahCare → Schedule a tour Contact CareChoice → Home care services
Written by Gary Murray, Chief Marketing Officer | CareChoice / SarahCare